Welcome to Lee University

Course Title: THEOLOGY 437

Subject: Systematic Theology

Professor: Dr. Donald Bowdle

Date: October 31, 1997 8:00 am

The following is a partial transcript of one of Dr. Bowdle's Theology classes. This is difficult to follow because it is transcribed as actually spoken except for some deleated stuttering. I have darkened and enlarged important sections and have also added my own comments in RED. On occasions I have not commented because the heresy left me speechless. Sometimes I only answered with scripture. The header, "J.T.'s Inserted Comment", precedes my remarks in green.

Dr. Bowdle:. . . O.K. um, another matter to consider, and I don't want to hide behind this. {the original language} It looks like, y' know, sometimes we can give the impression of doing it. Check the original language and see if it is really saying something about God changing. That would be very helpful. Uh, example, um, God repented that He had made man in the antediluvian world so He sent the flood. The word nacham in Hebrew doesn't mean repent, it means to be grieved. God was grieved at the mess that man had made of himself morally. So, we have Noah and the flood.

The word "repent" is not an appropriate translation there. God doesn't repent. As one writer says, God never says "oops" either like -- " I didn't mean to do that. Boy that got by me." Um, but you know there's allot of pop-theology out there that says that. Pop-theology is not, is no theology. Um, but, but allot of people see God as having plan "B" if "A" doesn't work and plan "C" if "B" doesn't work. There's just a plan. That's all. And then another is, and maybe this relates here, uh, Brother S.

Um, the Bible might be using anthropomorphism. You're familiar with that term from Christian Thought probably. O.K. a-are do we? Did you have that? I don't want to use a term, uh, and not define it an' maybe assume that you've been exposed to it and haven't. It's {anthropomorphism is} using human speech patterns to get across an idea because we're trying to explain God don' and can't do very well at that. {J. Thorpe's inserted comment -- Dr. Bowdle means that he or the people at Lee are trying to explain God but don't and can't do very well in their efforts.}

God doesn't change his mind, God doesn't have plan "B," but the drama that is presented where there is this anguish on the part of Moses here. It's presented that way. Is the Bible lying? No, it's not lying, it's good literature. Is that O.K.? Boy I know some people that would take me to task for that. Um, but it is good literature. Remember that we've got to allow the writers as intelligent as they were to write good literature. And that is depicting Moses' anguish over what's going on. But um, he didn't change God's mind. If you or I get sick and have a terminal illness, and were gonna' die, and we pray, and God heals us, and God does that of course; did God change his mind? No.

I do not know all of the dynamic involved in prayer and God's will. I had a class write on that one time. Their they discussed the dynamic of prayer in relation to God's will and boy was that a tough paper. I probably graded as leniently on the content of those papers as anything I've done in my life. How do you get a handle on that? People really agonized over that paper trying to come to some resolution of the problem because they knew they needed this. Um, and I wanted to learn and we all kinda' felt hangy even after we had spent some time with it. I don't pretend to know all the dynamic, but God doesn't change His mind. He doesn't change his mind depending on how hard I pray, how loudly I pray, how long I fast. He just doesn't do it. He was going to heal me anyway.

J.T.'s Inserted comment

(When Dr. Bowdle said, "I probably graded as leniently on the content of those papers as anything I've done in my life." he gave a clue as to what is happening at Lee University. Theology papers are graded on the basis of doctrine and intellectual expression! This would be fine if the required doctrines were those of the Church of God or even fundamental Evangelical faith. This transcript shows that Modernistic Calvinism is being taught and affirmed at Lee. Additionally, the Doctor's syllabus causes us to see, that the student must demonstrate an acceptance of his alien ideas. Thus, when attending Lee, the young Christian will be forced to desert the doctrines of the Church of God and Jesus Christ.)

Dr. Bowdle: The concern, and the prayer, and the intimacy, that go into the prayer with God for something, helps me as a Christian. It does not change God. I know I'm like the salmon swimming up the theological stream here in our circles, but I fully believe that. I can't change God's mind by how good I live or how bad I live.

Who was it that said in chapel, uh, last year maybe, I'm not sure. There's nothing I can do; how did he say; there's nothing I can do to make God love me more. There's nothing I can do to make God love me less. He just loves me and He's got a plan for me, and I've got to be spiritual enough to try to discern that plan and agree with God that what ever it is, is best for me.

J.T.'s Inserted comment

The Doctor says, "What ever it is, is best for me." {This attitude effects our unilateral disarmament in the face of the enemy. Accepting whatever comes is not best for us, nor is it God's plan. We are predestinated for destruction by Satan. God has ordained an alternate plan but God's plan can only be effected through prayer and faith. Without prevailing prayer and faith we cannot please God. Salvation springs from the cross and is established by faith, as are the balance of God's many blessings. Such faith reaches out past our dark circumstances and becomes creative and can and will alter our world. We must agree with God and lay hold of our inheritance or God's plan will never be realized in us! God want's participating sons and not yelping puppy dogs

Facing a Dilemma

Why do prayers and faith sometimes seem to fail? Doesn't everyone die in the end? If we lay hold of God's provision by faith and then do not see physical results, this does not indicate a failure of God or our faith. All faith will be rewarded when Christ returns and a delayed fulfillment of faith will later appear as the "better resurrection." Those who indulge in lazy faith and fail to believe will not be partakers of the blessing in this life or in the life to come. Our faith changes the world today and will raise us up at Christ's coming. Faith must be exercised for healing today and for the Rapture tomorrow!

We are informed by Dr. Bowdle that our prayer is not a catalyst of earthly change. We declare that the prayer of faith must come before change can be seen. Further, when a miracle happens without prayer, someone was praying but we were just not aware. God has many secret intercessors in his kingdom!

Dr. Bowdle: Now that's not easy, and I don't pretend always to be able to do it either. But that's who the Christian is. We can't dictate to God, we can't scream at Him to get his attention and twist his arm and get Him to change. He's simply not going to do that. So what do you do when you get sick? You pray like crazy because were supposed to. Does that change God? No. It changes us. I don't understand all about the dynamic. I, I'm sorry. Nobody else does either, so I'm in pretty good company. You just don't change God's mind.

J.T.'s Inserted Comment

Blind Bartimaeus

"And he cried, saying, Jesus, thou son of David, have mercy on me. 39 And they which went before rebuked him, that he should hold his peace: but he cried so much the more, Thou son of David, have mercy on me." Luke 18:38-39

If we call, God will answer!

"Call unto me, and I will answer thee, and show thee great and mighty things, which thou knowest not." Jeremiah 33:3

Jesus explained the dynamic of prayer.

"Hitherto have ye asked nothing in my name: ask, and ye shall receive, that your joy may be full." John 16:24 }

[Student: (This question could not be heard on the tape.)]

Dr. Bowdle: I think so. Yeah, I, Yeah I, I can't add any thing to that. That's very good. Uh, something else? Yeah, Yeah, I think your question was a good one and one of the best examples that could be given on this matter. Uh, Brother K.?

[Student: So is it possible that looking at God from His perspective on eternity, He knows what we're going to pray before he creates us and therefore knows how He'll react to us in our lives?]

Dr. Bowdle: Yes, I think all that has been pre-determined.

[Student: So, so I, I guess what I'm trying to say is like for example, Brother G. gets sick tomorrow and the doctor says he's gonna' die and Brother G. has]

Dr. Bowdle: Why are you smiling when you say that? (Students laughing)

[Student: Something strange happens and Brother G. all of a sudden has a great prayer life. Na, I'm kidding. Uh, but he prays and he's healed. So is it possible to say that God knew Brother G. was going to pray and decide to spare him because in eternity past He knew that he was going to pray that prayer.]

Dr. Bowdle: Yeah, but I'm not sure that knowing he was gonna', I'm not sure that Brother G.'s praying had anything to do with it.

[Student: O.K.]

Dr. Bowdle: God knew he would, but I don't think that it had anything to do with it.

J.T.'s Inserted Comment

{In Dr. Bowdle's teaching we read that all of our prayers are ineffective for altering the physical course of life and its circumstances. If this line of thinking is followed to its logical conclusion, we will finally do away with the sinners prayer and the altar call. Many misinformed Calvinists have done just that! We base this contention upon well known Church History and present Calvinistic practices.

In the early 1800s, Charles Finny related how that those that belittle the power of prayer were not even born again! These felt that God would do it all and human prayer was ineffective. Finny wrote of his Presbyterian pastor and mentor, who, did not have a converted heart and yet believed he was predestinated and chosen of God. Later this same pastor found a glorious conversion and anointing of the Holy Ghost and admitted that he had never before been Born Again! Finny also wrote of many ministers who had lost their faith during their Princeton education. Finny refused to attend Princeton, because, he did not wish to become like the Princeton graduates he knew.

We believe that Dr. Bowdle's Princeton learning has also spoiled his Evangelical vision and faith. The old Presbyterian Scots Worthies all knew what it was to wrestle with God and prevail. Again, if we deny the power of healing and prevailing prayer we will eventually deny the power of the sinners prayer. These two cannot be separated!}

[Student: O.K. so, I, I'm just trying to see if there's any real power or any real substance to the prayer itself that prayer caused any decision, is what I'm trying to say.]

Dr. Bowdle: I don't think so. I think that there are places in scripture like Brother S. was mentioning that make it appear so, but I think it is good literature depicting Moses' perception of what's going on because he's the one struggling, God's not struggling, Moses is struggling. Uh huh.

J.T.'s Inserted Comment

{Does the prayer of faith have substance? "Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen." Hebrews 11:1

Furthermore the inspiration of Scripture is denied in the above statements.

2 Peter 1:21 "For the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man: but holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Ghost."

Isaiah 51:16 "And I have put my words in thy mouth, and I have covered thee in the shadow of mine hand, that I may plant the heavens, and lay the foundations of the earth, and say unto Zion, Thou art my people."

Jeremiah 1:9 "Then the LORD put forth his hand, and touched my mouth. And the LORD said unto me, Behold, I have put my words in thy mouth."}

[Student: Hezekiah is another one too.]

Dr. Bowdle: Hezekiah is another one. Oh yeah. Yeah. And he didn't do anything productive those last fifteen years did he. Uh, brother J.?

J.T.'s Inserted Comment

(Hezekiah kept his wicked son Manasseh off the throne for 15 years. This proved to be a great blessing for God's people!)

[Student: How do you respond if someone were to say well uh, what's the sense in prayin' if we just trust you know God, then there's really no since in prayin' if it in God's plan and will to heal us then]

Dr. Bowdle: We are to pray and to leave it with God. Pray earnestly and leave it. Cast all your care upon Him. We do while we're praying and then we take it back and bear it. Uh,

[Student: Tustin' that He's caren' for us.]

Dr. Bowdle: Yes, you do pray. That is scripturally important. I'm not sure why necessarily except what He does tell us. We pray and leave it with God who has a will for us and He's smarter and knows what's better for us than we do. Now, let's bring it to the tragedy of Sister W.

Everybody has got a time and a way to die. God knows what it is. That is factored into our experience from the foundation of the world. God knew she was going to die. God knew she was going to have an accident. There is nothing that could have happened that could have spared her from that accident. That was her time and her place. You've got one. I've got one. All of us have one. I honestly meant to believe that. Um, Brother W's son, Brother P., after whom the arena is named, as you know was killed in a car wreck, and his wife was almost killed in a car wreck, um, same wreck. Um, number of years ago as he was going home from uh, college. He had graduated and was visiting and on his way back somewhere in Georgia, and someone driving on the wrong side of the road, and I don't know the circumstances, and uh, brother P. met head-on.

Brother L., do you know Brother L.? He was kind of a Guru here in the academic community. He was one of the few people left who had any contact with the founding persons of the Church of God. His dad was M.S. Lemons, one of the ministers. So he would uh, bring to many pastoral classes here an' at the seminary observations from our history first hand. Very, very fine man. He said, um, one time in a discussion with a small group about Brother W. accident, he said: look, there is a law of physics that says that two objects when in opposite directions on the same track are going to collide. That is a basic law of physics. God just knows how and when I'm gonna' die; and how and when you're gonna' die, and nothin's gonna' change that, I'm sorry, it isn't. Um?

[Student: How would you define I guess the actual purpose of prayer? ... how would it affect or for instance other persons that we pray for]

Dr. Bowdle: I think that first of all, I think its a, its a matter of obedience. We bear one another burdens and so forth all to Christ. Take it to the Lord in prayer. Casting all your care upon Him 'cause he cares for you. We're mandated to pray about it. We become better people, we become by the praying we become more able to see God's purpose and if we can't see the purpose we become more readily able to submit to whatever God's purpose is though we can't understand it than we would without it. But I don't; I, I remember uh, in, in my uh, folks home a little plaque that said: "prayer changes things." Prayer does change things. It changes the way I look at circumstances. It doesn't change the circumstances, as I said. So we are mandated to pray. Uh, it doesn't move God to do something that uh, he had decided not to do. I cannot understand all the dynamics of prayer. But God doesn't change in His being, in His promises, in His purposes.

[Student: If prayer isn't a catalyst then uh?]

Dr. Bowdle: It is a catalyst

[Student: I mean towards God as far as the way it affects God, not the individual. I'm saying as far as God is concerned, it's not a catalyst in causing God to do something. Then why sometime when people are prayed for, why are they healed immediately after prayer, or, do you see what I'm saying?]

Dr. Bowdle: Yeah. I can't answer that.

[Student: O.K. I just wanted to know.]

Dr. Bowdle: Yeah, Why, why for example did Jesus heal (snapped finger) like that and on at least one other example He prayed for a blind man, the blind man saw human beings like trees. Jesus prayed again and then his focus came. I don't know. Y' know I wonder that too. I don't know. Why does God heal some and not others. Is it because they prayed hard or they had more faith? No. Great question! I don't have a way to answer it. Sister G.

[Student: I, I was going to comment on that. I had epilepsy which is incurable, and from the time I was diagnosed with it when I was seven, I prayed almost every church service. I went for prayers to be healed. I was fifteen years old before I was healed. It, that was God's time. Any other time He could have had it been his will, but he didn't]

Dr. Bowdle: And we don't always know why you had to be fifteen in God's mind, uh, at a certain time and at a certain place but it was important to God. It had to be good. That's a great testimony Sister G.

[Student: Um, two things. I think prayer for the most part (tape noise) God made us emotional beings. I think one of the best things about prayer is just the fact that it couldn't change God's mind but it helps me through all of my despair and grief and everything that is inside of me out onto God so He can bear it, and I can't, and that helps me release all of that on Him (tape noise) it gives me the assurance that He's taking care of the situation.]

Dr. Bowdle: And what your saying isn't some kind of counseling technique, It's scripture isn't it? (tape noise)

[Student: Benny Hinn also has a book at home, which I'm not suggesting that um, is right, I'm just saying that they're out there. But as far as uh, praying, also prayers which, uh, I don't want to say cause God to do things for you, but are ]

Dr. Bowdle: I used that at Lee College along time ago. ... Um, Augustine said, this isn't the way he put it but this is what he meant. Um, immutability and eternity are flip sides of a coin. Y' have to look at them together. Immutability is the idea that God is devoid of all change as we said in His being, in His promises, and in His purposes. Eternity could be identified as the infinity of God in relation to time; the infinity of God in relation to time.

Notice how closely immutability, or changelessness and eternity go together. They are almost necessary complimentary attributes. When my kids were little, I stood them up against the door casing periodically and uh, put a ruler on top of their heads like maybe your parents did for you and made a little mark on the door casing and put a date there. Y' know it doesn't (break) I could see changes in my children. The way I know I'm getting older, is because of changes that I observe in other things and changes in me, too. Change is an attribute of material. Change is an attribute of time. God is neither material nor time.

We know that time is passing primarily because of changes we observe. We don't know that time is passing by merely flipping the calendar over. We know time is passing because we are changing, uh, intellectually, physiologically, biologically, societally, um, and this is very, very true the older you get. You know, you observe change and you know time is passing. With God, if you know there is no time, or if God is an eternal being, then change can not be part of His capability; if you want to put it that way; not part of God's experience. . . .

END

---------------------------------------------------------

Three quotations from above
with three verses to ponder
.

    Dr. Bowdle said:

  1. "Immutability is the idea that God is devoid of all change as we said in His being."
  2. "Change is an attribute of material. Change is an attribute of time. God is neither material nor time."
  3. "With God, if you know there is no time, or if God is an eternal being, then change can not be part of His capability; if you want to put it that way; not part of God's experience."
POINT 1.
Hebrews 2:16-17 "For verily he took not on him the nature of angels; but he took on him the seed of Abraham. 17 Wherefore in all things it behoved him to be made like unto his brethren, that he might be a merciful and faithful high priest in things pertaining to God, to make reconciliation for the sins of the people."

POINT 2.
Galatians 4:4
"But when the fulness of the time was come, God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, made under the law,"

POINT 3.
John 1:1
"In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. . . . 14And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us . . ."

An additional verse from Philip:

2 John 1:7 "For many deceivers are entered into the world, who confess not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh. This is a deceiver and an antichrist."

 

 

Return to My Lee University Home Page